For When People Are Hard to Love (4th, 5th, 6th Commandment)
I would like to appeal to your humanity. Humanity sounds nice, doesn't it? It's such a beautiful word. Humanity. Makes me think of people coming together, helping each other, making the world a better place.
Like those heartwarming stories in the Saturday newspaper? The human-interest section. A little girl raises $10,000 selling lemonade to help her classmate with cancer. A stranger pays for an elderly person's groceries. We read those stories and think, "You know what? Humanity’s pretty great."
I love those stories.
Studying the humanities in school means studying literature, history, philosophy, art. All the great human achievement. Sounds so nice.
But then I leave the house and come face to face with actual humanity.
And find out it’s a collection of selfish, inconsiderate, irritating people who seem to have organized themselves around the singular purpose of making my life more unpleasant.
I mean, I guess I love the idea of humanity. It's people I have a problem with.
I get teared up watching a video of some guy rescuing a baby elephant from the mud, but someone insists on having a toothpick in their mouth while talking to me and I'm reconsidering whether the human race was really a good idea in the first place. Or they suck their teeth, or click a pen, or tap on the table—anything like that—might as well stick a screwdriver in my ear and poke me in the eye.
What I’m trying to say is, humanity seems like a beautiful, inspiring idea. But actual human beings are painful… And if I haven’t already made it clear by how easily I’m annoyed, I’m one of the worst.
But I don’t think I’m alone. We all agree loving people is good. In theory. We're all for it. We just have a lot of expectations about how people ought to behave if they’re going to get any love from us.
We respect someone if they respect us. We’re kind if they're kind. We'll forgive them if they apologize. Maybe. If we think they mean it. And if we feel like it. We'll be patient as long as they don't keep doing the same stupid things over and over.
We all have entire systems worked out to determine how much love somebody deserves. We always deserve their love and respect, of course. Somehow we always come out looking pretty good in our estimation. Because when we do something they don’t like, we have our reasons. We’re justified. We were tired. We were stressed. We didn’t mean it. But when somebody else does something we don’t like—well, they’re just showing us who they really are.
We always judge ourselves by our intentions and everybody else by their behavior. It's a perfect system to make sure we’re always in the right.
We do it with everyone, even the people closest to us. Our parents, our kids, our spouses. People we've known for years. All the people we love who can make us the most miserable.
This is a sermon about loving people, but loving someone doesn't mean it’s okay for them to abuse us. Sometimes the best thing we can do is get away from somebody who's dead set on hurting us.
But what we’re talking about today is how to love and serve the people in our lives in normal situations. How hard that is for us. The way we act like people have to deserve our love before we have to give it. You know, treat people fair. Treat them the way they treat us.
And that sounds reasonable until we think about how God loves us.
We're continuing our series on the Small Catechism, going back to the basics of the Christian faith. Today we're looking at what we call the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Commandments. Parents, murder, and adultery. So this should be fun, right?
People have asked me about that picture on the screen for this series—what are those two towers? Is it New York or Mordor? They’re supposed to be the two stone tablets the Commandments were written on. What theologians call the two tables of the Law. The first one tells us how to love God. The second one tells us how to love our neighbor.
Remember when Moses came down from the mountain carrying them? Two handwritten love letters, written by the finger of God Himself. Easily the most valuable things that have ever existed. Moses had to be pretty excited to show them off.
But what did he find when he got back to camp?
His brother leading the people in worship around a golden calf. Ugh. The same people God had just rescued from slavery in Egypt. He'd parted the Red Sea. But they thought dancing around a cow—breaking the first commandment—was a good idea.
So Moses smashed the tablets—threw them on the ground. If there was ever a moment of instant regret…
Did he completely lose his mind? Why would he do that?
I heard something recently I thought was interesting. What if breaking those tablets was, in some sense, an act of mercy? What if Moses thought it might somehow spare the people from God’s judgment? Like tearing up the contract before it goes into full effect.
The Bible just says Moses was angry, and the covenant was already in place. But considering what Moses did next when He went back to God and pleaded for the people, it’s an interesting idea.
We'll come back to that.
Let's look at these commandments about loving people.
The Fourth Commandment: "Honor your father and your mother."
What does this mean? Let’s read this together: "We should fear and love God so that we do not despise or anger our parents and other authorities, but honor them, serve and obey them, love and cherish them."
That covers a lot more than, “mind your parents.” It includes “other authorities.” When Moses dug into teaching this commandment in Exodus and Deuteronomy he didn’t just talk about mom and dad, he also said “don’t curse your rulers,” “honor the elderly,” and “respect the judgments of people who administer justice.” So when it says to honor, serve, obey, love, and cherish… it’s about more than just mom and dad. But it does start with them.
And it doesn't say honor them if they’re honorable. They’re not going to be. It also doesn’t say they’re always right. If you're a parent, you know parents aren't always right. A lot of time we're just making it up as we go and hoping the kids don't figure it out.
God puts people over us to take care of us. He gives us parents, teachers, pastors, bosses and other authorities for us to submit to. To teach us humility. It’s not always going to be easy—wouldn’t have to be a command if it was. Of course, it doesn't mean obeying them if they tell us to sin. But it does mean we don't treat them with contempt just because we don’t agree with them.
Paul says this is the first commandment with a promise… “that it may go well with you and that you may live long in the land.” And I think that goes way beyond what my mom used to say, “I brought you into this world and I can take you out.” Which brings us to…
The Fifth Commandment: "You shall not murder."
What does this mean? All together… "We should fear and love God so that we do not hurt or harm our neighbor in his body, but help and support him in every physical need."
Notice it doesn’t just say, "Don't kill anyone." It also says we’re supposed to help people. There’s always a positive aspect to the commands.
And then the Sixth Commandment: "You shall not commit adultery."
What does this mean? One more time, together… "We should fear and love God so that we lead a sexually pure and decent life in what we say and do, and husband and wife love and honor each other."
This is God telling us to protect marriage, be faithful to each other, and not be creepy pervs.
So three commandments about how to love people. Love honors people. Love protects people. Love is faithful to people and treats them with dignity.
And we might be feeling pretty good about some of these but then Jesus comes along and turns it up to eleven.
In Matthew chapter 5, the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus does a deep dive on these commandments—and He makes them a lot worse.
Matthew 5:21-22 says,
"You have heard that it was said to the ancient ones, 'You shall not murder;' and 'Whoever murders will be in danger of the judgment.' But I tell you that everyone who is angry with his brother without a cause will be in danger of the judgment; and whoever says to his brother, 'Raca!' will be in danger of the council; and whoever says, 'You fool' will be in danger of the fire of Gehenna."
Well, dang. Up until this point, a lot of us were feeling pretty good about not having murdered anyone. Had a solid track record on that one.
But Jesus says God sees what's going on in our heart. The anger. The resentment. The contempt. The way we look at someone made in His image and decide they're not worth our time.
And we might also be feeling pretty good about not ever calling anyone "Raca" but since that just means calling someone an idiot—probably not working out so great for any of us who pay attention to politics.
Then Jesus moves to the Sixth Commandment in verse 27...
"You have heard that it was said, 'You shall not commit adultery;' but I tell you that everyone who gazes at a woman to lust after her has committed adultery with her already in his heart." Matthew 5:27–28
So much for “no harm in looking.” And for those of you looking for loopholes, gazing at men isn’t any better. I liked it better when I thought the commandments were just about what we've actually done. Who does Jesus think He is saying it’s a sin what happens inside our heads? Well… He’s God. And He’s fully aware of what a pornographic culture we live in…
And He still says deliberately looking at another person and thinking about sex with them, undressing them in our mind, making them an object for our mental pleasure is already adultery in our heart.
Then He goes on to say… and this sounds crazy…
"If your right eye causes you to stumble, pluck it out and throw it away from you. For it is more profitable for you that one of your members should perish, than for your whole body to be cast into Gehenna. If your right hand causes you to stumble, cut it off and throw it away from you." Matthew 5:29–30
I think He might be using hyperbole, I don’t think Jesus is actually giving us instructions for self-mutilation. But He is using shocking language to show how serious God takes sin. Because cutting off our hands or plucking out our eyes wouldn’t really solve anything, we'd still have the same sinful heart. He’d probably have something to say about throwing our phones away, though, instead of taking the chance that God will sick His angels on us. Jesus mentions hell twice in this section. When Jesus says Gehenna, that’s what He’s referring to, they all knew that. And hell is the ultimate, devastating isolation that comes from a heart spending a lifetime choosing itself over everyone else. Which is the opposite of love.
That's the thread running through all these commandments. Love. God gives us neighbors to love. But we keep finding ways to make relationships all about ourselves.
And we kind of know that already, which is why we keep looking for the minimum requirements, so we can justify ourselves.
We hear "Honor your father and mother," and we think about whether our parents actually deserve our respect. We can certainly remember times they didn’t. We compare the way we treated our parents with the worst people we know. That way, we’re not so bad.
We hear "You shall not murder," and we probably haven’t. But all that stuff Jesus said about anger, calling people names—the way we hold grudges and avoid people.
We hear "You shall not commit adultery," and we want to define the terms. How far is too far? Do flirty conversations count as adultery? When do fantasies cross the line? Is it adultery if it’s just on our phone?
We're always looking for loopholes. Ways to justify ourselves.
It all goes back to the First Commandment. We're supposed to fear, love, and trust God above all things. But we don't want God to tell us what love looks like. We want to decide. We want our feelings to determine what's right. We want to be God. And when other people let us down, we look for reasons why we don't have to love them.
But imagine if God treated us the way we treat other people.
Imagine if His patience only lasted as long as ours does. Imagine if He didn’t love us until we really loved Him first. If He withheld His grace until we finally got our act together. Imagine if He would only forgive us if He was completely satisfied with our apology and repentance—if He’d only save us once we made everything right.
We'd be in trouble.
Because we can't go back and unsay the words. We can't undo what we’ve done. No amount of promising we’ll do better changes what we already did.
If our salvation depends on how good we are at loving people, we're toast.
But thanks be to God, your salvation doesn't depend on how well you've loved other people. It depends entirely on how Jesus has loved you.
This is what it says in Romans 5:8,
"But God commends his own love toward us, in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us."
And then it says:
"For if, while we were enemies, we were reconciled to God through the death of his Son, much more, being reconciled, we will be saved by his life." Romans 5:10
Enemies. Seems like a strong word.
Jesus didn't die for people who were easy to love. He died for His enemies. People like you and me.
Remember Moses coming down the mountain with those stone tablets? You know what happened after he smashed them?
He went back up the mountain, and said this to God...
"Oh, this people have sinned a great sin, and have made themselves gods of gold. Yet now, if you will, forgive their sin—and if not, please blot me out of your book that you have written." Exodus 32:31–32
That's something. These were the same people who'd complained about Moses, questioned his leadership, and made his life miserable. If anyone had a reason to be fed up with humanity, it was Moses.
But instead of asking God to wipe them out, Moses offered himself. “Blot me out of Your book.”
Fortunately, God didn't take him up on it. Not that it would have helped anything… Moses couldn't take away their sins. He was a sinner himself.
But it’s amazing what Moses was willing to do. And then think about Jesus.
Because thousands of years later, someone much greater than Moses would stand in that gap between sinful humanity and the judgment of God. He’d plead for people who'd rejected Him, betrayed Him, and wanted nothing to do with Him. He’d also offer Himself in their place.
And this time, the sacrifice would actually be enough.
Jesus wasn't just another sinner offering to take the punishment for other sinners. He was the sinless Son of God. He'd kept every one of those commandments.
Jesus had remained faithful, even when everyone rejected and abandoned Him.
And He didn't just offer to die for all the rebellious people. He actually did it.
Even for you.
Your selfishness. Your anger. Your unfaithfulness. Everything you've done that you wish you could take back. He took it all and died for it.
And He rose from the dead. Your sins have been paid for. Death has been defeated. He’s not waiting for you to prove you're worthy of His love.
He already loves you.
Like it says in Ephesians 5:1-2,
"Be therefore imitators of God, as beloved children. Walk in love, even as Christ also loved us, and gave himself up for us…"
He calls us beloved children. Not probationary children. Not children who might be loved if they behave themselves. Beloved children.
That's who you are in Christ. In your Baptism, God put His name on you and connected you to Jesus' death and resurrection. You’re in the family.
And when you come to the Lord's Supper, Jesus doesn't give you a performance review. He gives you His body and blood, given and shed for the forgiveness of your sins.
You don't have to wonder whether you’ve been good enough to deserve God's love.
You haven't. And Jesus loves you anyway.
So what about the people in our lives that can be hard to love?
He told us to "walk in love." We're learning to live as the people He's called us to be. Imitate God, one step at a time.
Which means we can honor somebody without agreeing with everything they believe. We can respect our parents, teachers, pastors, and public officials without pretending they're perfect. Or respectable. Or Honorable. Honor them anyway.
We can do what we can to not feed our anger. We don't have to win every argument. We don't have to say that devastating comeback. We don’t have to respond evil for evil. We don’t have to write that social media comment. I know that's disappointing—been working on that response for three days, and it's magnificent! The devil will do fine without our help.
We can practice in our closest relationships. Where it’s most difficult. Every day of our marriage isn’t going to feel like a romantic comedy. Some days are going to be more like a reality TV show about two exhausted people trying to figure out what to eat for dinner without ripping each other’s faces off.
Faithfulness is love in the small moments.
And when we fail, and we will, confess it. Just apologize without needing to explain why the other person was more wrong than we were. Make up with people as soon as possible—and at the same time, realize forgiveness doesn't erase the consequences of sin or automatically restore trust.
These commandments show us what love looks like in our ordinary lives. With actual people. And when we blow it, we come back to the same Jesus who forgives us and keeps working in us through His Word and the Holy Spirit.
So for the love of humanity, people! Yeah, it’s going to be a struggle. People are the worst.
But I don’t think I’m any better. I know every selfish thought I've had, every resentment I've held onto, every stupid thing I've done. God knows all those things even better than I do.
And He loves me anyway. Same with you.
Not just some imaginary version who finally gets everything right. He loves who we actually are. Sinners who needed Jesus to die for us.
That's the love that sets us free to love all the difficult people God puts in front of us. Including the one we see in the mirror.
It won’t always be hard. The day is coming when we will truly love other people, honor other people, and live in peace with everyone, no matter what they’ve done to us. Can you image such a thing? I can only imagine. Until that day… Peace be with you, and may God the Father and the Lord Jesus Christ give you love with faithfulness. AMEN.
Prayer
Father in heaven, thank You for loving us when we were so difficult to love. Thank You for sending Jesus to take our sins to the cross, forgiving us when we didn't deserve it, and calling us Your beloved children. Help us to see the people in our lives as people You love. Give us patience when we're frustrated, mercy when we're hurt, and the freedom to love others as You have loved us. In the name of Jesus, our Savior. Amen.